All the False Stories You Have Been Hearing about AI. Science Fiction and Smart Weapons
Posted by Tirthankar RayChaudhuri on Nov 13,2023
A number of negative statements which are misleading in nature about the discipline of Artificial Intelligence have been written and circulated in the past. An increased level of such ignorant maligning of the technology continues unabated today via various online channels.
In the following table we call out these incorrect assertions, explain why they are incorrect and present the corrected notions.
Serial No |
Statement |
Origin |
Why incorrect |
Corrected version |
1, |
AI algorithms do not scale up to address real world domains in robotics and language processing |
Lighthill Report (1973) by James Lighthill. |
The fact that we have advanced robotic inventions such as self-driving vehicles and autonomous drones in operation today and large language model solutions such as ChatGPT and Google PaLM2 in circulation, proves that Lighthill’s pessimistic assertion 50 years ago was clearly an entirely wrong one. |
There has been much achievement and product development in the areas of robotics and natural language processing by applying AI/ML algorithms. |
2. |
We do not really understand how deep learning works and how machines learn |
Various individuals and groups |
Machine learning algorithms are based on advanced mathematics which requires a specialized knowledge background to comprehend them thoroughly. A number of individuals who do not have the background to understand the workings of these advanced systems end up stating that we cannot really understand them. |
Every machine learning system/algorithm is based on advanced mathematical models which are human designed and encoded hence we do know exactly how they work. |
3. |
Machines will develop the capability to design other machines which will eventually take over the world and destroy humans. |
Stephen Hawking, late English cosmologist and physicist |
Professor Hawking who was seriously ill for many years made this statement just before he passed away hence his prediction should not be considered seriously.
|
Although some automatic coding capabilities are now in place we are nowhere neardesigning machines that can design other machines, let alone make autonomous decisions to kill people. |
4. |
Enterprise AI agents are off-the-shelf plug and play products which can learn on their own and make decisions |
Marketing teams presenting misleading hype |
To be effective Enterprise AI systems require to be trained on business domain data before they can be used to predict, detect optimize and recommend. Such data requires to be engineered and pre-processed prior to being fed to an AI/ML agent. Periodic retraining is necessary for the levels of effectiveness to be retained and improved. Thus AI solutions for enterprises being domain specific, are not plug and play in nature. |
Enterprise AI agents must be customized within the intended business domain before they can be truly effective in augmenting human decision making. |
5. |
AI will lead to massive job reduction, unemployment and strife within society. |
Various pessimists some of whom may be influenced by highly fanciful video game creations depicting androids taking over various human work functions which is very far from today’s reality. |
AI is today a multi-billion dollar industry which has already led to the creation of thousands of new jobs. As per The World Economic Forum’s ‘The Future of Jobs Report 2020’ AI can potentially generate 97 million new roles in the next 5 years. |
Although a certain number of manually executed jobs will be replaced by newly introduced methods of automation the introduction and growth of new technology such as AI/ML requiring new skillsets has already created thousands of new job opportunities. |
6. |
AI-based systems produce biased results and are unreliable. |
Sponsors of failed AI projects |
It is essential for a machine learning model to strike a balance between bias and variance in order to produce accurate results. A machine learning model also needs to be adequately verified with test data before being deployed for business use. Not following such best practices will lead to an unreliable model. |
Best practices of model design and test data based verification are both essential factors for an AI system to be built for reliable operation. |
7. |
AI works exactly like a human brain |
A general common misconception which is widespread. |
While AI systems have been developed by researchers attempting to emulate the reasoning capabilities of the human brain, the AI systems that we have developed today are incapable of replicating many of the complex and advanced abilities of the human brain such as intuition and instinct. |
|
8. |
AI will lead to the creation of systems which will autonomously decide to kill people. |
Science Fiction books and films |
The fanciful notion of machines who decide autonomously to kill humans is pure science fiction. Some well-known examples are provided in the next section. Unfortunately the impact of such science fiction movies on people’s minds is rather significant. Nonetheless regulatory measures are needed for AI and all advanced technology to avert the danger of extreme misuse. |
Using AI for nefarious objectives can be only human driven and not autonomously perpetrated by a machine however intelligent it might be. This is because AI-based systems are human-designed and can do only what they are trained to do. However the risk of misuse of the intelligent technology for harmful intent is indeed a grave concern hence regulatory measures for designing AI systems are essential. |
Science Fiction Movies on ‘Killer AI’
Named below are a couple of very well-known science fiction films which depict artificially intelligent machines killing humans on their own.
- The 1968 movie 2001 A Space Odyssey portrayed a supercomputernamed HAL 9000 managing various controls of a spaceship traveling to Jupiter. HAL decided to turn rogue, destroying the lives of hibernating human spacecraft passengers whose oxygen supply was within HAL’s control before the captain of the spaceship took action and disconnected HAL’s electronic brain.
- The 1984 film Terminator depicts a cybernetic organism (cyborg) which looks like a human but is really a killer machine designed to assassinate people.
Weapons Powered by AI
Its important for readers to be aware that AI-powered ‘smart’ weapons have existed for a couple of decades at least. Across the world today defence departments of various governments have allocated significant budgetary spend for the development of smart weapons such as guided missiles and unmanned aircraft (drones) for launching military attacks. Th author of this Blog is not in favor of smart weapons being developed in this manner and strongly believes that international military regulatoryagreements and treaties must be in place and regularly updated to restrain the use of such weapons by rogue politicians.